Fiberglass vs Gunite vs Concrete Pools in Florida: Cost, Lifespan and What Works in Tampa Bay Soil
Short answer: in Tampa Bay, both fiberglass and gunite pools work well. Fiberglass wins on speed, low maintenance and a lower starting price; gunite wins on custom shapes, size, depth and the ability to remodel later. And “concrete” is not a third option: gunite is simply the way a concrete pool shell is sprayed. We build both at G&S Pool and Spa, so this is simply what we tell homeowners in Riverview, Brandon and the rest of Hillsborough County when they ask which pool belongs in their yard.
Concrete, gunite and shotcrete: same family, different spray
A concrete pool is a cage of steel rebar shaped to the design, then sprayed with concrete to form the shell. Dry mix that meets water at the nozzle is gunite; pre-mixed is shotcrete. Both cure into a rigid shell finished with tile, coping and plaster, quartz or pebble. The strength comes from the steel design, the shell thickness and the crew, not from the word on the estimate.
A fiberglass pool is a one-piece shell molded in a factory, trucked to your street and lowered into the excavation by crane. We install them as an authorized San Juan Pools dealer, with 109 models in our pool models catalog: 74 pools, 13 pool-and-spa combos and 19 spas. Fiberglass in-ground pools sit on our services page and home page for a reason: for many Tampa Bay families they are the right call.
How the build differs on a Tampa Bay lot
Fiberglass: days of open hole, not weeks
Once Hillsborough County issues the permit and the shell arrives, we dig, set a compacted base, crane the shell in, level and plumb it, and backfill while filling it with water. Most fiberglass installs are typically 2 to 4 weeks on site including deck and equipment. That matters here: from June through September an afternoon downpour can fill an open excavation, and a rain-filled hole in sand means re-cutting walls.
Gunite: built in place, inspected in phases
A gunite pool is excavation, plumbing, steel, a county steel-and-bond inspection, the gunite shoot, a cure period, tile and coping, deck, plaster, fill and start-up. Typically 8 to 12 weeks or more, longer with a raised spa, water features or a screen enclosure. The trade-off is total freedom: the shell is whatever the drawings say it is.
Hurricane season changes the schedule for both
We do not leave an open excavation or an unbackfilled shell in front of a named storm. A finished gunite shell rides out weather; a fiberglass shell must be full of water before a storm and stays full afterward. To swim before the wet season, a fiberglass install started in late winter or spring is usually the shortest path.
Sandy soil and a high water table: the Florida factor
Most of Hillsborough County is sand over clay and limestone. Near the bay, in Apollo Beach, Ruskin and Gibsonton, groundwater is often only a few feet down, especially after summer rains. On the higher ground of Valrico, Lithia and parts of Brandon we typically get more room. We confirm it on every dig.
- Gunite in wet ground: we dewater with well points while the steel goes in and the shell is shot, and we install a hydrostatic relief valve in the main drain so the pool cannot lift the day it is drained for resurfacing.
- Fiberglass in wet ground: an empty shell weighs a small fraction of the water it displaces, so in saturated sand it can float, the “pop-out” you may have read about. We fill the shell as we backfill so water inside and stone outside rise together, dewater during the set, and tell every owner never to drain it without calling us.
- Backfill: we backfill fiberglass with crushed stone, not sand. Sand washes out in summer rains and leaves voids behind the walls; stone drains and stays put.
Lifespan, maintenance and resurfacing
Gunite. The shell lasts for decades; the interior finish does not. Plaster in Florida water typically needs resurfacing every 10 to 15 years; quartz and pebble stretch that out. Plaster is porous, so it needs regular brushing, more chemicals and closer pH management in our heat. Resurfacing alone starts around $10,000 in our 2026 quotes and runs to about $25,000 when tile and deck are redone at the same time.
Fiberglass. The gelcoat is non-porous, so algae has fewer footholds, brushing is lighter and chemical use is lower. There is no resurfacing cycle; over a couple of decades the gelcoat can fade or chalk. Osmotic blistering was a real problem with older shells; modern laminates use barrier layers to address it, and manufacturers back the shell with structural warranties measured in decades. We put the exact terms in writing before you sign. Fiberglass also pairs well with salt chlorine systems.
What you cannot do later. A gunite pool can be remodeled, extended, re-tiled or given a new spa. A fiberglass shell cannot be reshaped; repairs are possible, but color matching is harder.
Fiberglass vs gunite at a glance
| Factor | Fiberglass | Gunite / Concrete |
|---|---|---|
| Shell | One-piece factory shell, set by crane | Steel cage sprayed with concrete on site |
| Time on site | Typically 2 to 4 weeks after delivery | Typically 8 to 12 weeks or more |
| Shapes and size | Catalog models up to about 45 ft long and 16 ft wide (road-transport limit) | Any shape or size; raised spas, vanishing edges |
| Depth | Up to about 8 ft in our deepest models | Whatever the engineering allows |
| Interior finish | Smooth, non-porous gelcoat | Plaster, quartz or pebble; porous |
| Resurfacing | No cycle; gelcoat can fade over decades | Plaster typically every 10 to 15 years |
| Chemicals and upkeep | Lower; pairs well with salt systems | Higher; plaster raises pH and feeds algae in summer |
| High water table | Can float if drained; needs stone backfill and dewatering | Needs dewatering and a hydrostatic relief valve |
| Changing it later | Cannot be reshaped | Can be remodeled or extended |
| What we quote | Usually below a comparable gunite pool; quoted per site | $57,000 to $150,000+, with spa and screen enclosure at the top of the range |
What each one costs in Tampa Bay
Across all of our new pool construction, custom pools start at about $57,000 and most projects land between $57,000 and $150,000+. Every yard is different: deck size, equipment, water features, enclosures and site access move the total. Rather than quote a figure we can’t stand behind for your lot, here is what a real project looks like at each step up in scope.
- Fiberglass, compact — lowest entry point. A Sedona Beach patio-style shell with about 300 sq ft of deck, crane, permit and engineering, equipment, electric and excavation.
- Fiberglass, family size. A Biloxi Beach model with a 6-ft beach entry, about 350 sq ft of deck, salt system, LED light, crane, permit and engineering.
- Gunite, custom — middle of our range. A 12 x 24 L-shape pool with a 6 x 6 sun deck, sheer-descent water feature, bubblers, salt system, about 350 sq ft of pavers and footers for a future screen enclosure.
- Gunite with spa and enclosure — top of our range, $150,000+. A 14 x 25 pool, raised 6 x 6 spa, about 1,600 sq ft of flagstone pavers, a 3,500 sq ft screen enclosure, permits and start-up.
Financing is available, and we offer a veteran and military discount. We price from a free 3D design of your actual lot — not from a price list.
Which one should you choose?
Choose fiberglass if
- You want to swim this season, not next.
- Low upkeep matters more than a one-of-a-kind shape, and a beach entry or built-in spa from a proven model is enough.
- Your all-in budget sits in the lower half of our range and a crane can reach the backyard.
Choose gunite if
- You want a shape, size or depth the catalog does not offer, or a pool longer than about 45 ft.
- You want a raised spa spilling into the pool, a vanishing edge or a sun shelf tied into a paver deck and screen enclosure.
- Your lot slopes or a crane cannot reach it; a gunite hose reaches where a crane cannot.
- You expect to remodel, extend or re-tile years from now.
Permits, HOA and screen enclosures apply to both
Every pool in Hillsborough County needs a permit with engineered drawings, and Florida’s residential pool safety rules require a barrier: a fence, an alarm or a screen enclosure with self-closing doors. Most Riverview, Apollo Beach and Brandon communities also require HOA architectural approval. We pull the permit and submit the HOA paperwork for you, and if a screen enclosure is in your future we pour the footers at the pool stage so nobody cuts your new deck later. José holds all three state licenses the job needs — Jose L. Gomez Algarin — CPC 1460544 · CGC 1532993 · CFC 1433412 (the CFC plumbing license is held by G&S General Contractor LLC) — so we are authorized for every part of the work.
Fiberglass vs gunite in Florida: your questions answered
Are fiberglass pools good in Florida?
Yes. Fiberglass handles Tampa Bay heat, summer rain and salt systems well, and the non-porous gelcoat means less brushing and fewer chemicals than plaster. What matters here is a crushed-stone backfill and never draining the shell in our high water table.
Can a fiberglass pool pop out of the ground in Tampa Bay?
Only if it is drained while the water table is high, because an empty shell weighs far less than the groundwater pushing up on it. We fill the shell as we backfill, dewater during setting, and ask every owner to call us before draining for any reason.
How long does a fiberglass pool take to install compared to gunite?
Once the permit is issued and the shell is delivered, a fiberglass pool is typically 2 to 4 weeks on site including deck and equipment. A gunite pool typically takes 8 to 12 weeks or more because the shell is built in place, cures, and passes county inspections between phases.
Is a gunite pool the same as a concrete pool?
Yes. Gunite is one way of spraying concrete over a steel rebar cage to form the shell; shotcrete is the other. Both are concrete pools finished with plaster, quartz or pebble and tile. In Florida, concrete pool almost always means gunite.
Which is cheaper in Tampa Bay, fiberglass or gunite?
Fiberglass is usually the cheaper of the two for a comparable size, because the shell arrives finished and the install is faster. Our custom pools start at about $57,000 and most projects land between $57,000 and $150,000+, with a gunite pool plus raised spa, pavers and a screen enclosure at the top of that range. Every yard is different, so we price from a free 3D design of your lot.
Get a free 3D design for your yard
Not sure which way to go? Send us a photo of your backyard and your must-haves, and we will build a free 3D design in both fiberglass and gunite so you can compare layout and price side by side. Call or text José at (813) 433-1723, or start your free 3D design and quote online. G&S Pool and Spa is veteran-owned and based in Riverview. See what homeowners say on our reviews page: we are rated 4.7 stars on Google across 26 reviews. Hablamos español.
Ready to build your dream pool?
Get a free 3D design and quote from Tampa Bay's veteran-owned, licensed pool builders.
Request your free quote See a pool in my backyard